This is Behind the Blog, where we share our behind-the-scenes thoughts about how a few of our top stories of the week came together. This week, we discuss election outcomes and code as a human endeavor.

JOSEPH: This week I got a real wave of ‘oh man this fucking sucks’ regarding AI. I won’t link to it because it’s just a rando person, but scrolling Reddit I saw someone who said they used Claude to build stuff with Max. Max, or Max/MSP, is a visual programming language that is heavily used in the world of music and visual art. It is the foundation of a lot of electronic music. You can build essentially anything in it, if you put in the work to understand how to put it together. And that can be a lot of work.

I’ve built various little things in Max. I made a tool that takes a drum break and generates new, random drum and bass style breaks from it. I am a big, big fan of generative music (both listening and making) where you create rules and parameters, press play, and let the rules decide what comes out. I made another that has various synthesizers, and from scratch manipulates the audio so they sound like Tibetan singing bowls, with their harmonies and individual melodies morphing over time. I also started working on the visual part of Max, called Jitter, to take audio output from Max and generate visuals.

These were deeply difficult to make, at least for me. I can code in Python, but this was of course learning an entirely new language, and one whose syntax (and everything really) is entirely different. It took lots of long nights of figuring out, okay, this device connects to this one, this thing goes here, okay, I’ve figured it out. 

It was painful, but of course it was also deeply satisfying. That is music creation, despite whatever the dipshit CEO of Suno will tell you. 

Code is a human endeavor. It can be for a lot of people a creative pursuit (it was for me for a while). But Max coding is especially human. It is code to create music. And now here was someone using Claude to bypass all of that. To cheat themselves out of the satisfaction of learning an instrument, or in this case a new musical language. I have no idea if they understand what Claude made, or whether they care. But this one was a real gut punch to me.

Music creation is one of the areas I do not want AI to touch at all (at least unless it is some very specific use case with the artist’s own data, or something similar). For years as a musician, I simply would not use other peoples’ samples because it felt like a shortcut, it didn’t feel like mine (I know this is an extreme position, and I love lots of sample based music, I just don’t want to make it). This is now even further: you want AI to not only make the music (like Suno), but also the tools that can help you create it in the first place. I dunno man, it just fucking sucks.

JASON: I held a few articles I’ve written this week back for next week because the election became the story this week, and rightly so. The main thing I published this week was my analysis of the election, which lots of you have said you liked and which a lot of people suggested I must have had fun writing. I did have fun writing it, thank you v much, but I also had a great time this week consuming the memes, the livestreams, the podcasts. Great week for content. 

If you’ll remember, after Trump got elected a second time, we started to see a handful of people cancel their subscriptions with us not because they said they didn’t like our work, but because they didn’t see what the point was. They figured it was all over, that journalism was useless, that there was not much that could be done to stem fascism in the country. The last two years have been brutal, about as bad as I thought they could be and in many ways worse. A day or two after his election, we all cowrote a piece called “Why the Work Still Matters.” If I’m being honest, I think we wrote it in part because we were scared that people would just mass unsubscribe from us because they felt greater despair, and we wanted to maybe convince ourselves a bit that we could still do this work under Trump. 

I’m going to quote from that piece at length for a second: 

“We cannot and will not make false promises to you about the power of journalism—especially at a small publication—to stop the country’s knowing march into authoritarianism. But we can explain our approach to the work and we can demonstrate to you why it matters,” we wrote. “We cannot set the bar for our success at the systemic saving of democracy. Instead, we have found that our work can and does make incremental positive change at the local, state, and federal level, and that, over time, these small improvements become increasingly important.  

“Our work is populist in that we recognize that many of the problems plaguing the United States today and which are factors that have laid the groundwork for Trump’s return—income inequality, a lack of affordable housing, unstable work, the widespread inability to tell what is real and what is fake—are being at least partially driven by technology and/or the immense wealth of the people who own tech companies,” we added. “Most of our articles tell the stories of hyperspecific communities of people who are using technology or are impacted by it in some way. By focusing on how technology impacts people, we have found that we can impact technology and make the world slightly better, regardless of who the president is.”

There’s lots more there. This was published basically exactly two years ago. Since then we have seen many terrible things happen; you’ve read about them on our website and elsewhere. I am too tired at the moment to dig through our archives or rack my brain for more about the horrors of the last two years. But we have also seen, as we hoped but couldn’t know for sure, people organize to support each other, grassroots movements against AI-powered surveillance, ICE’s brutality, Silicon Valley’s excesses, AI data centers, inequality, and more. 

We know for a fact that a lot of our work has led directly to incremental progress over the last two years. I don’t propose that our blogs created the wave we saw Tuesday, but we’ve heard directly from people who said our reporting inspired them to, for example, get an anti-ALPR license plate regulation put on their town’s ballot. Their town overwhelmingly voted to ban the tech. There are so many things that everyone who has been working for a better future has done over the last two years (and long before that), that made these election results possible, and that made Tuesday feel so satisfying.

It’s like the coin pusher game at the arcade. You diligently put quarter after quarter in and maybe it feels like nothing happens. I leave the arcade and you put some quarters in. Every once in a while, a few quarters come out the bottom that make you feel like maybe the game isn’t as rigged as you think it is. Eventually, something like Tuesday happens and zillions of quarters come out. Maybe a few of our quarters helped out. I don’t know if that metaphor makes any sense whatsoever, but it feels like Tuesday was something of a dam bursting. I’ve heard it described as the collective exhale after a decade of misery that has created the space for progress. There is so much more work to be done!

SAM: One thing I am really excited to see come of this week is the wholesale rejection of data centers specifically. Matthew Gault wrote a great writeup of how this played out across the country, so I don’t want to repeat it too much. But in the last year or so, the explosion of data center projects (and yes, everyone’s calling them “compute campuses” now, which a bunch of overly online people noticed this week too — they’ve been pulling that shit for a while now, but I don’t think the phrase is actually any more palatable than “data center” anyway so, who cares) have bummed me massively. They’re a huge, destructive, ugly, extractive symbol of what the tech industry has become, but instead of remaining concentrated in Palo Alto or in an Apple Store as physically cursed places, they’re taking up miles of land around the country, sucking dry everything around them, returning nothing but bullshit. In 10 years these warehouses will stand abandoned by all stakeholders and we’ll all get nothing but shitty tap water in return. Combined with Flock’s presence around the country, they’ve infiltrated our physical spaces in ways that make Big Tech’s impact on our lives impossible to ignore.

And I wonder if that’s part of what we’re seeing in these election results. As Gault wrote: "These midterms sent a clear message — people don't want to see data centers in their backyards,” Michael Whitesides, the deputy communications director for Local Progress, told 404 Media. “Across the country, people do not see the promised benefit of these data centers, and the AI they power, playing out in their daily lives. They're seeing basic goods and services get more expensive while these billionaire backed monstrosities take up space in their community, poison their air, and drive up their utility bills.”